The current FC Tucson roster has five players who have taken the field for the club in multiple seasons. One of those five is midfielder Erik Virgen, who also played for the Men In Black in 2017 and 2019.
* The other four players are Ramone Howell (2019), Carlos Merancio (2019), Raheem Somersall (2019) and A.J. Valenzuela (2018).
* A total of 88 players have played in two or more seasons for FC Tucson. Twenty-six players have taken the field in three or more seasons for the Men In Black.
* FC Tucson legend Dom Papa holds the record for playing in the most seasons. He pulled on the FC Tucson uniform for all or part of the season from 2011 to 2017.